Credit Suisse Collapsed. Who Benefited?
We are analyzing the aftermath of the most spectacular bank collapse in history. In this article we ask the oldest question in law: cui bono (who benefits?) because every collapse has winners and losers: UBS bought its rival for about CHF 3 billion and booked a gain nearly ten times larger, while Gulf investors and AT1 bondholders lost billions, cantonal banks collected the fleeing savers, and Hong Kong overtook Switzerland as the world's largest cross-border wealth centre.
NOVEMBER 13, 2026. FILIA PATER. APPR. 8 MIN.
Cui Bono?
Every lawyer learns this question in his first year, usually in Latin: cui bono, who benefits?
Peter Winzeler, the reluctant hero of Conspiracy Suisse, asks it in his own way when a strange old man walks into his office on Paradeplatz and claims a bank. Follow the money, and the motive will follow. The investigative journalist Lilith Bahti puts it more bluntly over a double espresso and her third cigarette: speaking of the bankers at the top, she says: "They're on their way out of the casino, Peter, quite sure that, on this occasion, the house will not win."
We are analyzing the aftermath of the most spectacular bank collapse in history and this article is the third installment in the series Credit Suisse, UBS, and Switzerland's Future. In the first article we asked: Three years after Credit Suisse collapsed, could UBS be the next to fail? In the second: Can Switzerland supervise, support or wind down a bank twice the size of its economy? Here we ask the question that every conspiracy theory begins with, and that every honest analysis should ask too: when the most spectacular bank collapse in history was over, who came out ahead, and who was left holding the bill?
The answer is not as simple as "the bankers won." But it is not that comforting either.
The Big Winner: UBS and the Bargain of the Century
UBS paid about CHF 3 billion for Credit Suisse, in its own shares. In return it received a bank whose net assets, even after heavy write-downs, were worth far more. Accountants call the difference "negative goodwill", or more colloquially "badwill". UBS booked a provisional USD 28.9 billion of it in the second quarter of 2023, later adjusted to USD 27.7 billion. The result was a quarterly profit of roughly USD 29 billion, a record for a European or American bank. To be fair, that gain was mostly an accounting entry. Much of it was needed to absorb the losses, write-downs and restructuring costs hidden in Credit Suisse's books, and UBS has spent three years doing exactly that.
Still, the long-term winner is not in doubt. UBS eliminated its only domestic rival of comparable size. It inherited Credit Suisse's Swiss corporate clients, its wealth-management relationships and its prime location on Paradeplatz. In January 2026, its share price reached its highest level since the 2008 financial crisis. Its management has done well too: CEO Sergio Ermotti, brought back in April 2023 to lead the integration, received CHF 14.9 million for 2025, and the group-wide bonus pool rose to USD 5.1 billion.
In the novel's last chapter, a fictional Lord Mayor of London complains on the BBC that "a bunch of nobodies grabbed the largest Swiss bank for pennies on the dollar." In real life, it was not nobodies who grabbed it, but it was very nearly pennies.
The Shareholders: Gulf Money Burned Twice
Credit Suisse shareholders received the equivalent of CHF 0.76 per share in UBS stock. In 2000, the share had been worth around USD 100, as we recalled in Fascinating Misfortune of Credit Suisse. For pension funds and small savers who had held Credit Suisse as a safe Swiss blue chip, it was a slow-motion catastrophe that ended in one weekend.
The most prominent losers came from the Gulf. The Saudi National Bank had bought a 9.9% stake only four months earlier, in November 2022, at CHF 3.82 a share. It lost around 80% of its CHF 1.4 billion investment, and its chairman, whose televised refusal to inject more capital had helped trigger the final panic, resigned within days. The Qatar Investment Authority, a backer since the 2008 crisis, saw a stake once worth almost CHF 4 billion shrink to about CHF 225 million. The Saudi-founded Olayan Group lost heavily as well.
Readers of the novel will recognise the setting. In Conspiracy Suisse, a fictional Qatari bank, QAB, buys 5% of SWB to strengthen its capital, persuaded by a vice president secretly working for a London banker. The novel's Gulf investors, like the real ones, discover too late that buying into a weakened Swiss bank is not the same as buying a Swiss bank.
The AT1 Bondholders: The Hierarchy Turned Upside Down
If one group felt robbed, it was this one. In every textbook, shareholders absorb losses first and bondholders after them. In March 2023, Switzerland reversed the order. Shareholders received about USD 3.25 billion in UBS stock, while USD 17 billion of AT1 bonds were written down to zero. AT1 bonds were invented after 2008 precisely to absorb losses in a crisis, and their fine print allowed a write-off. Nobody, however, expected one while shareholders still walked away with something.
Who held them? Large fund managers, for a start: PIMCO held around USD 807 million and Invesco around USD 370 million. PIMCO's loss was partly offset by gains on its senior Credit Suisse bonds, which rallied once UBS stepped in. The hardest hit were often wealthy private-bank clients in Asia, some of whom had bought the high-yielding paper with borrowed money and woke up to margin calls. According to the news site Semafor, even Credit Suisse's own senior staff had for years been paid partly in AT1 notes.
The story is not over. As we reported in Part 1, the Federal Administrative Court ruled in October 2025 that the write-off was unlawful, and the case now sits before the Federal Supreme Court, with some 3,600 investors waiting. Here is the twist worth watching: in the days after the wipe-out, dealers were buying the worthless claims for about 2 cents on the dollar. If the Supreme Court sides with the bondholders, the biggest winners may turn out to be not the original investors, but the distressed-debt specialists who bought their claims for pennies.
And who would pay? Possibly FINMA, possibly the Confederation, possibly UBS. Three years on, nobody knows.
Employees, Savers and the Quiet Winners at Home
The takeover added about 45,000 people to UBS overnight, bringing its workforce to almost 120,000. Since then, the combined bank has shed around 17,500 positions; UBS said early on that around 3,000 of the cuts would fall in Switzerland. For those employees and their families, there is no ambiguity about which column they belong in. Yet the same upheaval created a feverish job market for bankers who knew how to move: private banks and foreign institutions recruited Credit Suisse advisers, often together with their clients.
The quiet winners were the Swiss cantonal banks. When Credit Suisse savers ran, they ran to the most boring bank they could find, preferably one with a state guarantee. According to a study by the Lucerne University of Applied Sciences and Arts, about 82% of the Swiss savings that left Credit Suisse went to cantonal banks. Their share of Swiss customer deposits overtook that of the big banks. Raiffeisen, now the country's second-largest banking group, gained far less.
Swiss companies have a mixed balance. Credit Suisse had been the natural alternative to UBS for corporate loans. With that alternative gone, cantonal banks, Raiffeisen and foreign lenders such as Commerzbank moved in to compete for the business. Whether that competition can replace a second national champion is a question the coming years will answer.
The Rival Financial Centres: Hong Kong Takes the Crown
Zoom out from Paradeplatz, and the map of winners changes. For decades, Switzerland was the undisputed capital of cross-border wealth, the place where the world's rich kept money outside their home countries. The collapse of Credit Suisse did not end that, but it cracked the image of Swiss solidity at the worst possible moment. Deloitte noted in 2024 that inflows from European and Middle Eastern clients had yet to fully recover from the collapse. And in May 2026, Boston Consulting Group's Global Wealth Report found that Hong Kong had overtaken Switzerland for the first time as the world's largest cross-border wealth booking centre. Singapore is closing in behind.
Credit Suisse was not the only reason; Asia's wealth has been growing faster for years. But Sergio Ermotti himself warned that Hong Kong, Singapore and the US are aggressively competing for the offshore wealth crown, and that foreign centres would gain if Switzerland weakened its leading bank. That is the argument UBS now uses against higher capital requirements, and it is not without merit.
What about the Swiss state itself? On paper, it was a winner. The Confederation earned around CHF 200 million in fees on its guarantees and lost nothing, while the Swiss National Bank collected interest and a risk premium of CHF 476 million from Credit Suisse. In practice, Switzerland traded two big banks for one giant, and with it the risk we described in Part 2.
The Balance Sheet of a Collapse
So who really benefited? In the short run, UBS was the clear winner, without question: rival eliminated, record accounting gain (USD 27.7 bn negative goodwill for a CHF 3 bn price). The quiet winners were the cantonal banks (that picked up 82% of Swiss savings leaving Credit Suisse) and anyone nimble enough to pick up the pieces. The Swiss state and SNB were Winners on paper. But in the long run, the outcome may be less flattering for Switzerland: the rival financial centres inherited a little of the trust Switzerland lost. Hong Kong and Singapore may turn out to be the actual long-term winners (Hong Kong is now the largest cross-border wealth centre).
Employees of Credit Suisse definitely lost: nearly eighteen-thousand positions were cut since the takeover. So did the Credit Suisse shareholders (paid CHF 0.76 per share, the Saudi National Bank's loss reaching CHF 1.4 bn). Yet, there is one verdict still to come. If the Federal Supreme Court rules for the AT1 bondholders, who are for the time being the biggest losers of the whole ordeal (with CHF 16.5 bn having been wiped out), the final column of the balance sheet will have to be rewritten, and someone in Bern or on Paradeplatz will have to pay.
Epilogue
Next in Series: Could UBS Leave Switzerland?
Conspiracy Suisse has a clear suspect for who benefits from the weakening of Swiss banking: the City of London, embodied by Duke Robert William Burnthouse and his bank BRB. In the novel, Burnthouse's father tells his son that the Swiss are "eating too large a portion of our pie," and that the family must learn to control SWB. It is a provocative thesis, and we examined how much of it holds up in The Mind-Blowing Conspiracy of Bank Wars.
London did not emerge as a winner from the collapse; it lost jobs and prestige along with Zurich. The novel even anticipates this in its final chapter, when the fictional Lord Mayor laments on the BBC that BRB's stake in SWB and the City's holdings of SWB bonds are suddenly "worthless". But BRB of the novel is merely a symbol of outside influence and the real beneficiaries of Switzerland's wounded reputation sit further east, in Hong Kong and Singapore, and further west, in New York, where UBS is now said to be weighing a new home.
In another respect, the novel was uncomfortably close. Its central fear is that a great Swiss bank could be bought for a fraction of its value, at a moment of weakness, by those who understand its worth better than the public does. That is, more or less, what happened. If you want to see how a novelist imagined it all before it happened, start with the questions the book raises. You can read the first five chapters of the novel for free if you wish.
Sources
- UBS second-quarter 2023 earnings (UBS/Business Wire)
- UBS Group 2023 Form 20-F (SEC)
- UBS reveals how profitable the Credit Suisse acquisition was (Wallstreetcn/LongPort)
- UBS capital question in focus (Bilanz)
- UBS bonus pool rises 10%, Ermotti pay unchanged (Swissinfo/Bloomberg)
- Saudi National Bank loses over $1 billion on Credit Suisse (CNBC/NBC)
- Saudi National Bank chairman resigns (BreakingNews.ie)
- Credit Suisse losses make Gulf investors wary (Free Malaysia Today/Bloomberg)
- Asia investors gobsmacked by $17bn bond wipeout (FT via Today in the Markets)
- Pimco, Invesco face losses in AT1 write-down (Financial Advisor/Bloomberg)
- Who owns the worthless AT1 bonds? (Business Standard/Bloomberg)
- AT1 wipeout hits asset managers (WealthBriefingAsia)
- UBS sheds hundreds in latest job cuts (ThinkAdvisor/Bloomberg)
- UBS-CS outflows went to cantonal banks (finews)
- Credit Suisse takeover: winners and losers one year on (finews.asia)
- Deloitte wealth management centre ranking 2024 (finews.asia)
- Switzerland as a wealth centre (The Wealth Mosaic)
- Switzerland could lose wealth crown to Hong Kong (Swissinfo)
- Financial implications for the Confederation (Federal Department of Finance)
- UBS terminates federal guarantees (finews.asia)
Series: Credit Suisse, UBS, and Switzerland's Future
Forum Topic: Swiss Banking and the Collapse of Credit Suisse
Tags: Credit Suisse, UBS, AT1 bonds

Comments
Leave a comment